The Little (and Big) Things That Can Make or Break a Real Estate Sale

In real estate, we often talk about the big-picture features — location, layout, waterfront views, or investment potential.

But here’s something seasoned agents, lawyers, and inspectors will tell you: 👉 It’s often the little things that make the biggest difference.

We’ve heard countless stories over the years — from colleagues across the province and beyond — where a sale fell apart not because the home wasn’t right, but because of surprising, avoidable details that came up late in the process.

Let’s break down some of the most common issues that can make — or break — a deal, especially here in cottage country. 🏡✨

 

1. Structural or Mechanical Red Flags 🏗️

It doesn’t matter how stunning the lake view is — when inspection day reveals:

  • Foundation cracks,

  • Moisture issues, or

  • A roof nearing the end of its life…

Buyers often hit pause. Even manageable repairs can feel overwhelming, especially when they’re unexpected.

✅ Pro tip: Sellers who address or disclose issues early create more trust and smoother negotiations. Buyers should build inspection contingencies into offers.

 

2. Water, Septic & Well Surprises🚰

This one’s a familiar story in Muskoka and other rural markets. Deals can stumble over:

  • Low water pressure,

  • Septic systems that don’t pass inspection,

  • Shared wells without proper documentation.

These aren’t glamorous details — but they can turn excitement into hesitation fast.

✅ Pro tip: Having septic and well records ready (and up to date) goes a long way in protecting both sides.

 

3. Poor Internet or Cell Service 📶

More buyers than ever want a waterfront home and the ability to work or connect remotely. If they can’t make a phone call or log on reliably, it can be a deal breaker.

✅ Pro tip: Be upfront about connectivity realities. Many buyers appreciate solutions (like boosters or satellite options) over surprises.

 

4. Over-Personalization and Staging Misses 🛋️

A buyer’s first impression is powerful. When a home feels crowded, cluttered, or overly personal, it can be hard for them to picture their own life there.

✅ Pro tip: Neutral staging, soft lighting, and letting the property’s natural assets (like a lake view or great layout) shine can make all the difference.

 

5. Pricing That Doesn’t Match the Market ⚖️

Even a fantastic property can struggle to sell if the price isn’t aligned with current market conditions.

Overpricing often leads to:

  • Fewer showings,

  • Longer days on market, and

  • Price drops that raise buyer skepticism.

✅ Pro tip: Strategic pricing from the start positions your property for stronger offers.

 

6. Legal & Title Surprises (The Sneaky Ones) 🛑

Here’s where things can get complicated — and where preparation really matters.

Some of the most stressful deal interruptions come not from the property itself, but from what’s buried in the title or legal documents. Common culprits include:

📌 Encroachments

  • Docks or boathouses extending onto neighbouring lots.

  • Driveways or fences that don’t match the actual legal boundary.

🧭 Easements & Right-of-Ways

  • Shared laneways or private road access.

  • Utility easements or paths others are legally allowed to use.

🌊 Shoreline Road Allowances & Crown Land

  • Common in Muskoka — sometimes parts of a waterfront property aren’t technically owned by the seller unless they’ve been purchased or closed.

These types of discoveries can delay closings or even cause deals to collapse if buyers aren’t comfortable proceeding.

✅ Pro tip:

  • Sellers: get ahead of potential title issues with your lawyer before listing.

  • Buyers: order title searches early during conditional periods.

  • Everyone: work with legal professionals who understand rural and waterfront properties.

 

7. Miscommunication & Missed Details 📨

Sometimes deals don’t fall apart because of a property issue — they falter because of:

  • Missed deadlines,

  • Unclear expectations, or

  • Last-minute surprises between parties.

✅ Pro tip: A well-organized team — REALTOR®, lawyer, lender — with clear communication is often the unsung hero of a smooth transaction.

 

Final Thought: Little Things, Big Impact 💬

Every property has its quirks. But when sellers prepare well, buyers get clarity early, and professionals stay ahead of the curve — most issues can be solved long before they become deal breakers.

✨ Whether it’s a septic report, a title search, or a quick Wi-Fi test, a little foresight can protect a big investment.

Be where you want to be — without the last-minute surprises.

 

Over to You 📣

What’s the smallest or most unexpected thing you’ve ever heard of derailing a deal? Was it a quirky easement? A leaky tap? An internet dead zone? 👀

Drop your story in the comments below 👇

✨ Because the best transactions are the ones with no last-minute surprises.

 

👩🏻💼 Lisa Selvage | Muskoka Realtor® | Lifestyle Property Expert | Let’s connect!

👩🏻💼 Shirlene Johnston | Parry Sound Realtor® | Serving Parry Sound & Beyond

Share This Post: