Waterfront Wonders: 5 Must-Knows Before Investing in Muskoka’s Lakeside Properties

“Living on the lake isn’t just a dream—it’s a strategy.”

That’s what one of my clients said after buying their first waterfront home in Muskoka last year. And they’re right. Waterfront property isn’t just about peaceful mornings and dockside coffee (though that helps!). It’s also one of the smartest ways to build long-term wealth through real estate.

But here’s the thing: not all waterfront investments are created equal. In today’s market, demand is high, supply is low, and lakeside living has never been more competitive.

If you’ve ever dreamed about investing in Muskoka’s cottage country, now’s the time to get smart, not just emotional.

Let’s dive into what you need to know before leaping.

 

1. Why Muskoka Waterfront Property Still Holds Its Value

Despite changing markets, Muskoka remains a top-tier investment destination. Here’s why:

  • Scarcity of waterfront land – With strict zoning and environmental protections, waterfront lots are hard to find.

  • Global appeal – Muskoka continues to attract buyers from the GTA, the U.S., and overseas.

  • Hybrid lifestyles – More buyers choose to work part-time or fully remote from the cottage.

  • Rental potential – Waterfront cottages command premium weekly rental rates, especially from June to September.

💡 Did you know? The average price of a Muskoka waterfront property in early 2025 was over $1.3 million.

 

2. Current Trends: What the 2025 Market Is Telling Us

Here’s what I’m seeing on the ground in real-time:

  • Buyers are cautious but committed – There are fewer multiple-offer situations, but serious buyers are ready to pounce.

  • Inventory is still tight – Many sellers are holding onto their cottages, expecting another boom.

  • Cottages under $1M are vanishing – If you find one, you must move quickly.

  • Financing is a hurdle – Lenders are more strict with waterfront properties. Pre-approval is key.

📈 Pro tip: Properties with year-round access, good water depth, and modern septic systems sell significantly faster.

 

3. What to Look for When Buying Waterfront

Buying Waterfront isn’t just about the view. Here’s what savvy buyers always check:

  • Shoreline type: Sandy, rocky, or weedy? It affects resale and use.

  • Exposure: South-facing means more sun, but western exposure gives you killer sunsets.

  • Water access: Is it deep enough for boats? Safe for kids?

  • Seasonal vs. Year-Round: Four-season homes have higher utility but cost more upfront.

  • Septic and water systems: Get them inspected. Age and legality matter.

🚨 Red Flag: “Unorganized townships” may lack year-round road maintenance and building permits. Ask your local expert (aka, me!).

 

4. Real Stories: From Dream to Deal

Last year, I worked with a Toronto couple with a $1.5M budget and a vision of raising their kids by the lake. We saw 11 properties. The one they bought wasn’t even on their radar until I previewed it and FaceTimed them from the dock.

They now split their year between the city and Muskoka and rent the property weekly during August for $5,000/week. It pays for their mortgage and then some.

Moral of the story: Being flexible and having a local guide makes all the difference.

 

5. Takeaways: How to Make Your Muskoka Move Smart

Here’s how to approach this like a pro:

  • Get pre-approved and know your max

  • Work with a local realtor who understands lakes and backroads

  • Plan for hidden costs: septic updates, water tests, insurance

  • Act fast, but never skip due diligence

  • Consider rental income as part of your long-term strategy

💬 Remember: You’re not just buying a property; you’re buying a lifestyle, and that lifestyle should match your goals.

Let’s Chat: Are You Ready to Be Where You Want to Be?

Buying a waterfront property in Muskoka is a big move—and the right one if you do it smart.

Whether you dream about weekend getaways, a retirement plan, or your next investment, I’m here to help you navigate the docks and details.

📩 Message us directly or visit lisamselvage.com and allpointsnorth.ca to explore the latest listings, resources, and market updates.

 

Your Lakeside Expert | “Be where you want to be.”

👩🏻💼 Lisa Selvage, Realtor® | All Points North Group | eXp Realty

👩🏻💼 Shirlene Johnston, Realtor® | All Points North Group | eXp Realty

Share This Post: