Why Location Matters More Than You Think

You’ve likely heard it before: “Location, location, location.” But what does that mean for you as a buyer? Should you buy the beautiful turn-key home on a busy highway or the fixer-upper on a quiet, tree-lined street?

Spoiler alert: Smart buyers choose location, and here’s why.

The house you buy can always be updated. The location? Not so much. In today’s market, where values fluctuate and lifestyle drives decisions, your home’s location is its most powerful wealth-building tool.

 

🔍 Section 1:  The Case for Location Over Perfection

Here’s what you gain by choosing a better location, even if the home needs work:

  • Higher resale value: Desirable neighbourhoods consistently outperform when it comes to appreciation.

  • Easier resale: Buyers will line up for a dated home in a great spot, but few want a luxury home in an undesirable area.

  • Lifestyle benefits: Walkability, schools, access to nature or downtown—these things matter more than a fancy backsplash.

  • Lower long-term risk: A poor location can depreciate your investment. A good one cushions market volatility.

Real-life example: In Muskoka, we often see dated cottages sell in days just because they’re on a sought-after lake, while modern homes on small lots with road noise can linger for months.

 

🏠 Section 2:  The Allure (and Risk) of a “Perfect” Home in a Poor Spot

We get it—moving into a home that needs zero work feels great. But here’s the catch:

  • ❌ Limited appreciation in undesirable neighbourhoods

  • ❌ Longer time to sell if the area doesn’t attract buyers

  • ❌ Lack of community or lifestyle perks

You could overpay for features that don’t translate into future value. Buyers will always ask: “Yes, it looks nice… but where is it?”

Think of real estate like dating. You might fall for the looks, but it won’t last long if there’s no substance (aka location).

 

✨ Section 3:  Resale Value and Market Trends

What drives price in the long term?

According to real estate trends across Ontario, especially lifestyle-driven markets like Muskoka:

  • Location accounts for up to 80% of a property’s value.

  • Renovated homes in poor locations underperform, even with designer upgrades.

  • Homes in top areas can sell “as is” because of land value and neighbourhood demand.

As a realtor® and investor, we’ve seen homes double in value simply because the street or waterfront became hot. Renovations helped, but the location did the heavy lifting.

 

🌿 Section 4:  The Beauty of Buying “Ugly”

Here’s a mindset shift: What if the fixer-upper isn’t a burden but an opportunity?

Benefits of buying a home with potential in a great area:

  • ✅ Customize over time without blowing your budget all at once

  • ✅ Add value strategically through kitchens, bathrooms, and landscaping

  • ✅ Build sweat equity while watching your location boost your base value

This strategy works especially well in Muskoka, where homes near lakes, schools, or trails are in high demand. Buyers love charm and potential—especially when paired with a dream location.

 

💼 Section 5:  Take It from the Field (My Insight as a Realtor®)

We once worked with buyers who chose a “meh” house on a stellar street in Bracebridge. It needed everything—paint, floors, and a new kitchen. But three years later, thanks to smart updates and that unbeatable location, they sold it for over $200K more.

Contrast that with another family that bought a pristine home on a busy street. They had a hard time reselling, and the price barely moved.

The lesson? Location doesn’t just help you live better; it helps you sell better.

 

📅 Actionable Takeaways

Before you fall in love with finishes, consider these tips:

  • Start with a neighbourhood wishlist: Schools, safety, walkability, future development

  • Focus on potential: Can you renovate or expand?

  • Look past dated decor: Paint and flooring are easy wins

  • Don’t overbuy in a poor location: You’ll struggle to recover that value later

  • Ask your realtor (me!) for resale comparisons in both scenarios

 

✉️ Conclusion:  Be Where You Want to Be

In the end, the smartest home buyers think long-term. They see beyond granite countertops and focus on what truly drives value: location.

So next time you’re torn between “pretty” and “potential,” ask yourself: Will this place grow with me?

We’re here to help you figure that out. Whether you’re buying your first home or looking to invest in Muskoka or Parry Sound, let’s find you a location worth building your future on.

Be where you want to be.

DM or contact us to start your journey. ⬇️

👩🏻💼 Lisa Selvage | Muskoka Realtor® | Lifestyle-Driven & Wealth-Building Real Estate

👩🏻💼 Shirlene Johnston | Parry Sound Realtor® | Serving Parry Sound & Beyond

Location First, Renovate Later: The Smarter Way to Build Real Estate Wealth

Share This Post: